| 
                                            
 
BEFORE HONBLE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA 
(Original Civil Writ Jurisdiction) 
Writ Petition (Civil) No. of 2003 
IN THE MATTER OF  
APPLICATION UNDER ARTICLE 32 OF 
THE CONSTITUTION OF INDIA. 
IN THE MATTER OF  
Non-maintainability of Principle of finality of final order of the Supreme Court in respect of the provisions under Part III of the Constitution of India  
IN THE MATTER OF  
ARTICLE 13 OF THE CONSTITUTION OF INDIA 
IN THE MATTER OF  
Judgment of the Five Judge Constitution Bench (2002) 4 SCC Pages 388 and 425 Rupa Ashok Hurra v Ashok Hurra and another. 
IN THE MATTER OF  
Judgment of the Nine Judge Constitution Bench (AIR 1967 SC 1:(1966) 3, SCR 744) Naresh Shridhar Mirajkar v State of Maharashtra 
IN THE MATTER OF  
MILAP CHORARIA,  
(Previously known and called as Milap Chand Choraria) 
Son of Late Shri Deep Chand Choraria, 
A-47, Pal Mohan Plaza,  
11/56, Desh Bandhu Gupta Road, 
Karol Bagh, 
Delhi-110005 ..Petitioner 
Versus 
1. The Union of India, 
Through, Cabinet Secretary, 
Rashtrapati Bhawan,  
New Delhi-110004 
2. Home Secretary, 
Ministry of Home Affairs, 
North Block, 
Delhi-110001 
3. Revenue Secretary, 
Ministry of Finance, 
North Block, 
Delhi-110001 
  
 - Secretary,
 
Railway Ministry, 
Rail Bhawan, 
New Delhi-110001 
 - Secretary,
 
  
Ministry of Personnel, Public Grievances and pension 
North Block, 
New Delhi-110001 
6. Vigilance Commission of India, 
Through Secretary, 
Satarkta Bhawan, 
Central Pool Office Complex, 
INA, New Delhi  
7. Central Bureau of Investigation, 
Through Director, 
3, C.G.O. Complex, 
New Delhi-110003 
8. Chairman, 
Central Board of Direct Taxes, 
North Block, 
New Delhi-110001 
9. State of West Bengal, 
Through Chief Secretary, 
Writers Building, 
Kolkata-700 001 
10. Department of Urban Development,  
Government of West Bengal, 
Through Secretary,  
Writers Building, 
Kolkata-700 001 
11. Department of Cooperation,  
Government of West Bengal, 
Through Secretary, 
Writers Building, 
Kolkata-700 001 
12. The Office of the Registrar of Cooperative Societies,  
Government of West Bengal, 
1, K. S. Roy Road, 
Kolkata-700 001 
13. West Bengal Cooperative Tribunal,  
Government of West Bengal, 
Through Secretary, 
1, K. S. Roy Road, 
Kolkata-700 001 
  
14. Home (Police) Department,  
Government of West Bengal, 
Through Secretary, 
Writers Building, 
Kolkata-700 001 
15. Director General of Police,  
Government of West Bengal, 
Writers Building, 
Kolkata-700 001 
16. The Calcutta Police,  
Government of West Bengal, 
Through the Commissioner of Police, 
Lal Bazar Head Quarter, 
Kolkata-700001 
17. Behala Police Station,  
Through Officer-in-Charge, 
Behala, 
Kolkata-700038 
18. New Alipore Police Station,  
Through Officer-in-Charge, 
Kolkata-700053 
19. Kolkata Municipal Corporation.  
Through the Municipal Commissioner, 
5, S. N. Banerjee Road, 
Kokata-700013 
20. Bar Council of West Bengal, 
Through Secretary, 
2 & 3, Kiran Shankar Roy Road, 
Kolkata-700001 
21. Election Commission of India, 
Through Secretary, 
Nirvachan Sadan, 
Ashok Road, 
New Delhi-110001 
22. Law Commission of India, 
Through Secretary, 
Shastri Bhawan, 
New Delhi-110001 
23. Shri Gopal Subramanium, 
Senior Lawyer of Supreme Court of India, 
B-5/7, Safdarjung Enclave, 
Africa Avenue, 
New Delhi-110029. 
  
  
24. Shri S. Murlidhar, Advocate, 
Supreme Enclave,  
Mayur Vihar, 
Delhi-110092 
25. Shri Sanjay Kumar Jhunjhunwala,  
9/1, Lower Rowdon Street,  
Kolkata-700020 
26. Shri Manik Chand Sethia,  
Through Shri Bhikam Chand Ji Bhansali,  
M/S. Arbind Enterprises,  
Room No.731, (Nand Ram Market),  
4, New Howrah Bridge Approach Road,  
Kolkata -700001 
27. Mr. Chuni Lal Mukherjee,  
24E/1, M. N. Sen, Regent Park,  
Kolkata-700040 
28. Mr. Chittaranjan Ganguly, 
Village- Tetulberia, 
P.P. Garia, 
Kolkata-700088 
29. Mr. Kamlesh Chandra Chatterjee,  
13, J.K.Pal Road,  
Kolkata-700038 
30. Mr. Shrawan Kumar Bhatter, 
C/O, Shri Chandi Plastic Udyog, 
53A, Futnani Chambers, 
Kolkata-700001 
31. Mr. Sukumar Das, 
21, Seal Thakur Bari Road,  
(25, Binoba Bhave Road), 
Kolkata-700038 
32. Mrs. Ava Rani Dey 
10/10, Kali Charan Dutta Road, 
Kolkata-700088 
.Respondents 
To, 
The Honble Chief Justice of India and His Companion Justices of the Supreme Court of India, 
The Humble petition of the Petitioner above named, 
MOST RESPECTFULLY SWETH: -   
 |