His Excellency Shri A. P. J. Kalam,
Honble President of India,
Youre Excellency Sir,
Your Excellency Sir, I have sent an application by Post on Friday 25th June 2004
with request to Your Excellency Sir, kindly refer under Article 143 of the Constitution to the Honble Supreme Court of India
to form Opinion on important Issues relating to substantial question of Law relating to the Constitution.
Youre Excellencys "Dream 2020", can be achieved
only by establishment of the Rule of Law in true practice, a pre-condition for the true democracy.
Matter of my suffering was also examined by the Vohra Committee, appointed on the issue of by
the Government of India. After going through the matter, honestly one cannot claim or observe that my matter not discloses
reasonable cause for filing of a Writ Petition before Supreme Court. But, Supreme Court Registry is illegally determined to
justify that no reasonable cause has been disclosed in my Writ Petition to discriminate me against influence of Powerful Politician
and his patronized Mafia, and their Criminal acts and deeds. Even Ld. Mr. Gopal Subramanium, Sr.
Advocate, Supreme Court -though he was influenced against me by some one, before such admission-, admitted by his Letter dated
23rd May 1995 that "As far as the merit your matter is concerned I am
prima facie satisfied that there is a cause of action at least to file a Writ Petition under Article 32 of the Constitution
of India for appropriate reliefs"
. Learned Mr. Rajiv Dhavan, Sr. Advocate by his letter dated 4th
December 1995 referred that "Many thanks for your letter, which combines juristic
concern with the intensity of one having suffered personal atrocity"
Youre Excellency Sir, this is my further Humble Submission that no one can refer similar other matter, with
strong evidences, of atrocities having intensity suffered by me, having combined with simultaneous fighting for more than
last 20 years for my survival and protections of rights against Political-Crime-Nexus, and against embracement of the large
number of the Judicial Officers and my Advocates, which can be rated as rarest amongst rarest having caused through open misuse
of the Powers and abuse of the authority by powerful politician of India, none else than Shri Jyoti Basu, the then Chief Minister
of West Bengal, against one individual like me. Till such sufferings are going on, Your Excellencys dream 2020 cannot be achieved.
I know Your Excellency having scarcity of time. But in consideration of the importance of the matter, Your Excellencys direct
intervention is most warranted and essential just not to help me, but for the Rights of the Constitutional Remedy Guaranteed
to move before Supreme Court, which selectively infringed as may appeared from my matter. Formation of opinion on such important
issues will also ensure integrity, probity and accountability in the Supreme Court.
Youre Excellency Sir, this is my Humble Submission that in any case if Youre Excellency satisfy and hold
that from the facts referred in my Writ Petition (some of the extracts from the same are referred herein) no reasonable cause
to move Supreme Court seeking protection of the fundamental rights are disclosed, I will stop all further steps in the matter.
My basic problem is that I am having social background and never compromises against principles, as referred
at the Website: http://milapchoraria.tripod.com/msp.
Now Justice to me can be ensured only by Your Excellency Sir.
Youre Excellencys Law abiding Citizen
Mobile to SMS (P.P.): 9811342616
Extracts from the Writ Petition (Civil) filed under dairy No. 22474 of 2003 on 29th October 2003,
before Supreme Court of India are referred at: : http://milapchoraria.tripod.com/p2p
Facts relating to atrocity having intensity suffered by me cannot be stated or explained in one or two pages.
In fact, I not annexed each supporting document, even Writ Petition (Civil) Diary No. 22474 of 2003 filed by me on 29th
October 2003 before Supreme Court become a Petition of about 400 Pages.
However, extracts of very few incidents relating to misuse of Powers and abuse of authority causing infringement
of my Human and Fundamental rights were referred herein.
In 1981-82 one unscrupulous businessman turned Mafia was in employment for a salary of just Rs.300/- per
month, now a multimillionaires, not by earning through proper means, but due to misuse of powers and abuse of authority by
Shri Jyoti Basu the then Chief Minister of West Bengal, by various means and methods including support to blackmailing activities
of said unscrupulous businessman turned Mafia.
In or about 1982 and in 1988 I purchased about 56 and 10 Cottahs landed property respectively in Kolkata
from their absolute owners. In the meantime said Mafia also purchased neighboring properties and decided to grab my property
by any means. From subsequent events this was become ample clear that he had some unholy connections with Shri Jyoti Basu.
25/11/1983 I was lifted by force from the Court compound in presence of about 500 litigants,
Advocates and others, at the behest of Mr. Jayanta Kumar Dasgupta, the then Munsif Learned 5th
Court, Alipore (Kolkata), and implicated in a false case of theft of Court Records.
06/09/1984 On the basis of Complaint from me, and after enquiry Honble Kolkata High Court dismissed Mr. Jayanta
Kumar Dasgupta, from Judicial Services as the first such dismissal of any Judicial Officer in Indian Judicial History.
30/01/1985 I came to know from Area Dy. SP, that CM Shri Jyoti Basu directed District Magistrate 24-Parganas
to remove me from my absolute property, on false claims that properties was belonged to another person. D.M. directed to Area
Dy. SP to implement order of C.M. However, after my written representation, D.M. withdrew her earlier directions.
21/03/1986 I got sanction two Plans for multistoried buildings from Kolkata Municipal Corporation.
18/07/1986 Severe attempt to murder me took place with 42 stab wounds all over my body.
October 1986 and 5.11.1986 A story was conveyed and subsequently confirmed in writing by said Mafia that
I can be removed from my property with the help of Shri Bikes Kali Basu, the then Police Commissioner of Kolkata, if I would
not sell the property to him.
14/11/1986 Under instructions from Shri Jyoti Basu, Kolkata Municipal Corporation created fake Municipal
Holding No. 161/N, Binoba Bhave Road, Ward No. 119, Kolkata, in favour of one habitual and adjudged cheater. Surprisingly
before creation of said fake Municipal Holding Number said Mafia, referred such holding numbers in his two Letters to me.
19/03/1987 Under the instructions from Shri Jyoti Basu, Kolkata Municipal Corporation got received a Complaint
from said adjudged Cheater, and conducted following proceedings within 6 hours of one working day: (1) enquiry was directed,
(2) alleged Local inspection and enquiry was conducted (3) alleged 12 Page Typed Report (Without Type Writer facility) was
prepared by Mr. Tarak Banerjee in the language of said Cheater (4) alleged Report was submitted (5) Meeting of the respective
authority were held and alleged Report was accepted (6) My sanctioned Plans were revoked and (7) Local Police was directed
to stop my constructional activities.
31/03/1988 In the Writ Petition filed by me Judgment was pronounced by Kolkata High Court setting-aside aforesaid
orders of Revocation of Sanction Plans.
When they understood that blackmail me through Kolkata Municipal Corporation may not help much, then mafia
changed strategy. Under which deferent litigations were got filed against me.
30/05/1988 One litigation was started by a person who booked flat with me as Dispute Case No. 43/RCS/87-88
of West Bengal Cooperative Directorate to got pronounced illegal award with the help of Shri Jyoti Basu, through Cooperative
Department and Cooperative Directorate of West Bengal.
30/05/1988 My Vendors (Sellers of the property) published advertisement to give impression that they still
are owners of the properties, which they already sold to me.
02/11/1988 Kolkata Municipal Corporation issued Show Cause Notice upon me, with predetermined object to revoke
my sanctioned plan once again on some different grounds.
07/11/1988 Once again Kolkata Municipal Corporation revoked my sanctioned Plans on new but fake and completely
flimsy grounds that property have no passage and that the sanction of the Plan were obtain for excess than actual size of
09/02/1989 Kolkata High Court directed to Kolkata Municipal Corporation to withdraw its revocation Order
and permitted me to make construction in accordance with the sanctioned plans.
11/12/1989 Said Mafia threaten me that he "is in a position to use Shri Jyoti Basu, the then Chief Minister
of West Bengal to harass me", which he already using.
06/01/1990 From the certified Copy of the Entire Order Sheet of the said Dispute Case No. 43/RCS of 1987-88,
this was transpired that person who pronounced illegal award against me, was even not appointed as Arbitrator.
Between 02/02/1990 / 16/02/1990 After filing of the Appeal by me against such illegal award and receipt of
directions from Member, West Bengal Co-operative Tribunal, to send the records of the said Dispute Case No.43/RCS/87-88 the
then Registrar of West Bengal Cooperative Society, Mrs. Mira Pandey, Sr. IAS, (she was actively interested in the matter under
instructions from Shri Jyoti Basu) and Mr. Mihir Ranjan Choudhury, ARCS, got forged 1st and 2nd page
of the Order Sheet of the said Dispute case to insert the name of Mr. N. Goswami (I have unbeatable strong evidence of such
09/02/1990 Said Mrs. Mira Pandey, issued Unofficial Order No. 48 upon the State of West Bengal to issue Notification
-based on such illegal award pronounced by a Person, who was not even appointed as Arbitrator-, to takeover the management
of my Cooperative Society to make ways for acquiring the property by said Mafia.
20/04/1990 I filed Application under Section 340 of Cr. P. C. against forgery of said Order Sheet in Dispute
Case No. 43/RCS/87-88 which was registered as Misc. Case No. 3 of 1990 of West Bengal Cooperative Tribunal.
05/09/1990 I sent 2,000 Copies of 28 Pages Memorandum under heading "A MATTER OF THE CALCUTTA MAFIA and challenges
to ADMINISTRATION OF JUSTICE" to different authorities including President of India, all Members of Parliament, all West Bengal
M.L.A.s and all Kolkata Councilors and other various authorities.
18/01/1991 Under embracement caused by allotment of the property from Chief Ministers Quota just at the verge
of Retirement, Mr. A. K. Bhattacharya, WBHJS, the then Member of West Bengal Cooperative Tribunal, dismisses said Misc. Case
No.3 of 1990 (filed against forgery of Order Sheet) knowing fully recording false order in presence of myself and My Advocate
that the applicant (myself) and his Advocates were not present.
22/02/1991 Dr. Manash Bhunyan, M.L.A., (W.B.), fixed the date to raise the matter of atrocities suffered
by me in West Bengal Assembly, but under some conspiracy he changed his plan and on the very same day severe attempt to murder
of my son was caused under Police Protection by staging a Truck accident.
1991-1993 Within the same period, a Contempt proceeding was initiated against me by the said Mafia as I have
called him as "Mafia", and on the basis of the false Affidavit of Service, he in connivance with his Advocate obtained from
Kolkata High Court. But when I filed an Application under Section 340 Cr. P.C., against said Mafia, then on the one hand Mafia
arranged the matter out of the Court List, and on the other hand spread over in the Kolkata, the muscle men to kill me, as
a result I was flea from Kolkata to save my life.
26/03/1991 Under criminal connivance and by misusing Judicial Office, Ld. Mr. J. C. Moulick, the then Munsif,
5th Court, Alipore, ignoring 16 Rulings of different High Courts, referred in Writing by me, and the Principles
Laid down by Supreme Court, passed injunction order against me to support blackmailing objects, in the Suit filed by my Vendors
with knowing fully false statement relating to size of the property. In fact from the documents having with my Vendors their
predecessor have acquired 66 Cottahs of landed property, out of which they finally lost a case for the property measuring
10 Cottahs. Therefore, their ownership cannot go beyond the 56 Cottahs. But under manipulations in the their Suit against
me they falsely claimed the property as 94 Cottahs, without encroachment to some other property and even arithmetically was
1992 One Jai Chand Lal Sethia, (Partner of Mr. Rashid Miyan the main accused of Bahoobazar Bomb Explosion
Incident, reportedly in which, 300 Hundred persons were killed and was agent of the Dawood Ibrahim), threaten me on behalf
of Shri Chandan Basu, son of Shri Jyoti Basu. I sent a written complaint to Shri Jyoti Basu, which was replied by his Confidential
Assistant Mr. Jay Krishna Ghosh assuring me for appropriate steps.
08/07/1993 I submitted Application for according sanction to Dr. Shankar Dayal Sharma, the then President
of India, Under Section 19 of the Prevention of Corruption Act, 1988, and 197 of the Criminal Procedure Code, to prosecute
Shri Jyoti Basu, the (then) Chief Minister of West Bengal, with copy to Shri Jyoti Basu, himself by Regd. Post at his residential
address. Letter was confirmed by the Memo Letter No.406/3/93-AVD.IV dated 01/11/1993 from the Government of India, Ministry
of Personnel, Public Grievances and Pensions, Department of Personnel & Training. But even after repeated representations
thereafter no response.
24/07/1993 I negotiated with a Promoter for Joint Venture, who claimed that he will do the same on approval
from Shri Hashim Abdul Halim, Speaker of West Bengal Legislative Assembly. When said Promoter and myself met Shri Hashim Abdul
Halim, describing said Mafia as Powerful and offered to mediate between me and said Mafia.
Thereafter, I decided to move in Supreme Court, and at the behest of Ld. Mr. A. D. Giri, (Solicitor-General
of India, during Chandra Sekhar Government), I booked Mr. Gopal Subramanium, Sr. Advocate, but who was also influenced by
some one on behalf of the said Mafia, resultantly, I failed to move before the Supreme Court.
Finally I decided to move before Supreme Court as Petitioner-in-person. Since, I have a social background
as such in 1995 I filed a Writ Petition as Public Interest Litigation. I can say on affirmation that Affidavit, which applicable
today for candidates for Parliament and State Legislatures exclusively was my innovation. Please see detail in Website: http://milapchoraria.tripod.com/msp
Subsequently, I filed a Writ Petition with my own matter, but for some technical reason Honble Mr. Justice
as then was Mr. G. N. Ray suggested me to withdraw the said Petition, than I should file afresh. In the meantime, said Mafia
become fully active in Supreme Court, and when I filed fresh Writ Petition, the same should have been listed before the same
Court of the Honble Mr. Justice as then was Mr. G. N. Ray, but it was listed to some other Court, and on the basis of withdrawal
of said earlier Petition, said Court dismissed my fresh Writ Petition without hearing, but basing upon Court Report.
On 10th April 2002 a Landmark Judgment was pronounced in the Indian Judicial History by the Constitutional
bench headed by Honble Chief Justice as then was Mr. S. P. Bharucha admitting that mockery of Justice is possible within the
Supreme Court, and for the removal of the same a New Platform of "CURATIVE WRIT PETITION" was allowed. But, some conditions
were laid down in the Judgment. Fulfillment of one condition to file a certificate from the Senior Advocate was not possible
for me in considerations of large number of my Advocates ditched me in Past.
Thereafter in or about September 2002, I filed a Writ Petition challenging such conditionality of the Judgment,
but Writ Petition was refused to receive as a Writ Petition, by Supreme Court Registry, in serious violations of the Rights
of the Constitutional Remedy guaranteed under Article 32 of the Constitution. After a Long correspondence with the Supreme
Court Registry on 29th October 2003, I filed fresh Petition before Supreme Court, but, after withholding the same
for more than six months, once again said Petition was refused to "list before Honble Court", by backdated order dated 26th
May 2004 considering my complaint dated 26th May 2004 before then newly appointed Chief Justice of India Mr. R.
C. Lahoti. Considering such developments I submitted another complaint dated 18th June 2004 to Honble Chief Justice
P. P. : MOBILE: 9811342616
Enter content here
Enter supporting content here